All
Outcomes
Market
Price
AI Fair
Value
Value
Edge
Democratic Party
YesNo
Republican Party
YesNo
AI Insights:
03.12 12:57 UpdatedFair Value Reasoning:
Although the current market pricing slightly favors the Democratic Party (53c), the structural hurdle of OH-09's redistricting into an R+11 stronghold cannot be ignored. While incumbent Marcy Kaptur boasts a resilient personal brand and the 2026 midterm environment historically favors the opposition party (assuming Democrats against a GOP President), overcoming an 11-point partisan disadvantage is statistically formidable. The market appears to be overpricing Kaptur's incumbency advantage while underestimating the fundamental demographic shift of the new map. Therefore, we maintain a Fair Value that leans towards the Republican Party (Lean R), estimating their win probability at roughly 55%.
Sign up to view more information
Divergence
Significant divergence exists. The market price currently implies a 53% win probability for the Democrats, effectively rating the seat as 'Lean D' or at least incumbent-favored. However, mainstream political analysis (based on data like Cook PVI) would typically classify an R+11 district as a Safe or Strong Lean Republican seat. The market pricing is heavily relying on Marcy Kaptur's historical overperformance, which conflicts with the objective deep-red fundamentals of the district.
